As the sun came up on Election Day and bleary-eyed voters began to
make their way to polling locations throughout Connecticut, dozens of
lawyers were waiting.
For months, Democrats and Republicans had
been assembling teams of volunteer attorneys, with some assigned to be
poll monitors and others serving on "strike teams" that would file
emergency motions if voting problems arose. Starting three weeks before
the election, both parties offered training sessions, focusing on
potential issues in high-traffic polling places in Bridgeport, Hartford,
New Haven and Waterbury.
Such legal preparedness has become a
national phenomenon in recent election cycles, prompted by the disputed
Florida vote that ultimately decided the 2000 presidential race. Closer
to home, the 2010 Connecticut governor's race spilled into a courtroom
when Bridgeport election officials ran out of ballots and Democrats
successfully petitioned a judge to extend voting by two hours while new
ones were printed.
This year, with preelection polls showing
Democratic Gov. Dannel Malloy with the slimmest of leads over Republican
Thomas Foley, both parties ramped up their organization efforts—with
Republicans touting a 50-lawyer team and Democrats upping the ante with
80.
The potential for problems seemed especially likely this year.
A new procedure to allow for Election Day voter registration was
implemented for the first time in this election, which increased the
chances for long lines and potential confusion.
"I think both
sides were interested in seeing how the Election Day registration
process worked, because it was new," said Michael Goldfarb, a Murtha
Cullina attorney who is also general counsel of the state Republican
Party. "There were some long lines in some places, but I'm not aware of
anything improper occurring."
In spite of his personal
disappointment that Foley again lost to Malloy, Goldfarb was pleased
"with the integrity" of the electoral process in Connecticut this year.
He believes the presence of lawyers at polling places helped to
guarantee that integrity. "When you go into any polling location, there
are people who are doing the right thing and trying to be helpful, but
occasionally, because we have elections only once a year, poll workers
make mistakes," he said.
One example of such a mistake, he said,
was a polling worker who tried to allow someone to register to vote at
the polling location, "instead of sending them to City Hall." Having
legal volunteers on hand, along with observers who work for the
Secretary of the State's Office, helped "make sure the elections were
properly done," Goldfarb said.
Nationwide, there were the usual
array of ballot errors and computer malfunctions plaguing elections this
year. Dozens of precincts in Virginia reported voting machine problems,
and Colorado's electronic election system had to be rebooted. In one
Texas county, the name of a Republican candidate was found to be missing
from ballots.
Connecticut had its own 15 minutes of voting drama,
when a Hartford Superior Court judge ordered two Hartford polling
places to remain open for an extra half hour Tuesday. The court order
came after lawyers with Malloy's campaign filed for an injunction after
noting there were delays in the opening of at least 10 polling places in
Democratic-heavy Hartford on Election Day morning.
The volunteer
legal teams were called into action, starting at 5:55 a.m. The first
phone call came from a Democratic lawyer who had been camped out at
Hartford's Grace Lutheran Church. The lawyer reported to colleagues that
voters were already lining up, but the voting lists had not yet
arrived. Soon, other reports began arriving about late poll openings.
Within
two hours, William Bloss, one of eight volunteer attorneys who were on
standby for the Democrats, had started tapping out a request for an
emergency injunction. "The irony of being an elections lawyer is you
hope to have no work," said Bloss, of Koskoff Koskoff & Bieder in
Bridgeport. "I was hoping all I was going to do was check my email and
take phone calls. That hope vanished very rapidly after 6 a.m."
The
Democrats had also hoped to extend the polling hours by one hour. But
at 5:30 p.m., Superior Court Judge Carl Schuman ordered that two of the
city's precincts remain open until 8:30 p.m.
The Republicans' use
of volunteer lawyers came in handy in Hartford. In court, former state
GOP boss Herb Shepardson, a litigator with Cooney, Scully and Dowling,
was able to call on Republican lawyers to testify that voting had not
been affected at the polling places they were observing.
Peter
Martin, an Election Day volunteer for the GOP and a partner at Hinckley,
Allen & Snyder's construction law practice in Hartford, said the
group of lawyers and some nonlawyers who volunteered at polling places
made a difference in encouraging Schuman to keep the polls open for only
30 minutes, instead of the 60 minutes the lawyers for the Democratic
Party had sought.
"Because our volunteers were around in Hartford,
we were able to observe some of the issues that were going on," Martin
said. "As a result of that effort, at the court hearing, our attorneys
on the ground were able to provide the court with more information than
the other side had."
The GOP lawyers said, unofficially, they
heard the 30 extra minutes resulted in just 11 votes for Malloy. "The
volunteers served a couple of key purposes. First and foremost, we
wanted to make sure that anyone who had the opportunity to vote did
vote," Martin said. "And we wanted to make sure we had a fair process
and that all of the rules and regulations were followed."
Kevin
Reynolds of West Hartford, general counsel for the state Democratic
Party, said the party's 80-member legal team ranged from law students to
seasoned trial lawyers.
Early on, the Democrats had appointed
Joshua Scollins, a Quinnipiac School of Law graduate who previously
worked for U.S. Sen. Ed Markey's campaign in Massachusetts, as a vote
protection coordinator. Scollins was charged with recruiting election
monitors. To find them, he visited law schools and law offices.